Early Warning for Mosquito-borne epidemics at regional level

Laboratory of Atmospheric Physics, University of Patras (UPAT)

Centre of EO Research and Satellite Remote Sensing (BEYOND)

Introduction

...leveraging scientific knowledge and ultimately provin that Earth Observation can spend our understanding in the field of Epidemics...

Agenda



  • The BEYOND EO Center/EuroGEO Action Group on Vector-borne Diseases

  • State-of-the-art in the field of epidemics

  • Development of an Early Warning Decision Support System in Europe

  • Human infectious disease modeling related to climatic change conditions

  • Exploitation of satellite-based EO for Epidemics of mosquito-borne diseases

  • The Modeling Framework and validation of an early warning system at municipal (Greece) and regional (Venneto, Italy) level

Learning outcomes



  • Know about the development of an early warning system

  • Understand how EO data used to forecast human cases

  • Explain the application of an early warning system and its benefits on disease outbreaks


Laboratory of Atmospheric Physics

Research Axes

  • Weather and atmospheric pollution forecasting modeling
  • AI methods in atmospheric and environmental physics problems
  • Ultraviolet and solar radiation
  • Measurements, processing and homogenization of meteorological and environmental time series
  • Stable isotopes in rain and water vapor

eo4geo logo

The Space/Geospatial Sector Skills Alliance

Towards an innovative strategy for skills development and capacity building in the space geo-information sector supporting Copernicus User Uptake

erasmus_2

Copernicus Program:

Europe's eyes on Earth

copernicus-overview


Copernicus is the EU Earth observation program, looking at our planet and its environment to benefit all European citizens.

It offers information services that draw from satellite Earth Observation and in-situ (non-space) data.

The information services provided are free and openly accessible to users.

The EO4GEO project

  • Duration: 4 years from January the 1st, 2018
  • Budget: 3,87 million €
  • Partnership: 25 Partners + 30+ Associated Partners (from 16 EU Countries) from Academia, Companies and networks
  • Coordinators: GISIG (General), KU Leuven (Scientific & Technological), PLUS (Education & Training), Climate-KIC (Exploitation)

eo4geo consortium
The EO4GEO Consortium. 30th May 2018, Castellón de la Plana, Spain

The EO4GEO project


  • EO4GEO aims to bridge the skills gap between the supply and demand of education and training in the space/geospatial sectors, fostering the uptake and integration of space/geospatial data and services in a broad range of application domains.


  • EO4GEO works in a multi and interdisciplinary way and apply innovative solutions for its education and training actions: case-based and collaborative learning scenarios; learning-while-doing in a living lab environment; on-the-job training and co-creation of knowledge, skills and competencies.

EO4GEO IS MUCH MORE


EO4GEO offers a series of tangible results that are usable for the broader EO/GI education/training community

eo4geo much more

Early Warning for Mosquito-borne epidemics at regional level

basics

Let's start from the basics...

Mosquito-Borne Diseases in Europe

An emerging threat


Mosquitos & Diseases
  • Culex - West Nile Virus
  • Anopheles - Malaria
  • Aedes albopictus - Dengue, Zika, Chikungunya

EUROGEO

Action Group


EYWA is a vision, a network, a European and even global standard.

    EYWA offers a scalable, reliable and sustainable early warning system, relying on Earth observation big data combined with entomological, epidemiological and socioeconomic data, to forecast and monitor Mosquito-Borne Diseases.

    EYWA

      EYWA is built on the triptych:

      • ADVOCATE
      • ENGAGE
      • DELIVER

    EYWA

    EYWA TEAM

    "Together Everyone Achieves More"

    How EYWA competes?

    EYWA is a robust and scalable Early Warning & Decision Support System that welcomes new partners from around the world to share data and transform scientific knowledge into decision-making & mosquito control actions


    EYWA system architecture

    EYWA incorporates 10-years time-series of Copernicus (Sentinel-2) and other space-based data (Landsat-7 & -8, MODIS and ERA-5) in addition to in-situ entomological, epidemiological, socioeconomic and crowdsourcing data.


    EYWA system architecture

      A suite of APIs is developed and publicly available through BEYOND-NOA’s GitHub profile for automatic:
      • Data harvesting
      • Data Pre-processing
      • EO-based indices derivation
      Satellite data harvesting and processing, exploiting European and non-European services:
      • Umbrella Sentinel Access Point of the Hellenic Mirror Site (an API that constitutes 100% EU innovation and has been developed by BEYOND-NOA in the framework of the NextGEOSS and EOPEN EU projects)
      • CreoDIAS and Google Earth Engine

    EYWA system architecture

    EYWA system architecture

      A “mammoth” feature space of at least 10-years time-series of data for every mosquito-traps network in nine regions in Europe.

      How is this plethora of independent data transformed into meaningful scientific knowledge?


      EYWA has a factory of dynamic and data-driven models, learning about the dynamics of mosquitoes’ abundance and mosquito-borne diseases transmission, and providing monthly, weekly, daily predictions.

    EYWA system architecture

    the MAMOTH model

    • MAMOTH (Mosquitoes Abundance prediction Model autO-calibrated from features pleTHora)
    • Generic data-driven approach relying on open EO data
    • Automated Feature Selection:
      • No human bias on feature selection is injected in the model
      • Transferable and replicable
    • Knowledge expansion: Operating under the same architecture and the same mathematical principles to different cases, offers extensive capability of comparative studies, responding to: "which characteristics seem important in one case and which on the other?"
    • MAMOTH is composed of 32 (up to now)in-housed developed Python functions that are organized in 5 operational Modules

    EYWA system architecture

    Predictions results dissemination to the relevant Public Health Authorities through monthly reports and the EYWA Web Platform



    EYWA & open data sharing


      EYWA is an autonomous European Initiative, building upon the Open Innovation, Open Science and Open to the World vision for Europe.

      Analysis ready 10-years’ time-series of environmental, meteorological and geomorphological data for every mosquito-traps network in 10 European regions. Accessible through:

    EYWA in action

      EYWA’s operational implementation in 2020 (TRL>7 ) with a demonstrated impact in:
      • Greece (Regions of Central Macedonia, Thessaly, Western Greece and Crete)
      • Italy (Veneto region)
      forecasting Culex mosquito populations and West Nile Virus outbreaks in 2020.


      EYWA’s pre-operational test in 2020 for:
      • Culex (WNV) abundance prediction in Serbia (Vojvodina region) and Germany (Baden-Württemberg region)
      • Anopheles (Malaria) in Italy (Veneto region)
      • Aedes albopictus (Chikungunya, Dengue, Zika) in France (Grand Est and Corsica regions)

    EYWA in action

      EYWA is now fully operational in all these areas and started delivering results again for the 2021 mosquito season in the end of April.

    EYWA in action

    Reports with operational results

      EYWA produces knowledge in the form of reports, statistics, validated assessments and web GIS information layers, all available to the end-users through the EYWA Web Platform.
      The reports indicate:
      • Up-to-date epidemiological status of the Region
      • The state-of-the-art models used
      • The mosquito abundance predictions for the month
      • The estimated human risk
      The EYWA Reports:
      • are delivered operationally from April to October every year to the relevant Public Health Authorities and decision makers.
      • assist the authorities in organizing their mosquito control strategy and actions. Measurable performance indicators are used to evaluate the level of EYWA’s effectiveness toward the protection of the engaged communities against the disease outbreak.

    EYWA in a nutshell

    • Plethora of satellite Earth Observation data
    • Entomological, epidemiological, crowdsourced, socioeconomic and auxiliary data
    • State-of-the-art technological tools



    Leveraging scientific knowledge and ultimately proving that EO can upend our understanding in the field of epidemics


    The pivotal role of EYWA is to become a key lever for Public Health authorities and decision makers, support preparedness and timely strategic design of the health system response actions, and raise citizens awareness on the expected risk, with a view to fight Mosquito-Borne Diseases

    Partners

      Greece

        National Observatory of Athens (NOA) – BEYOND Centre of EO Research & Satellite Remote Sensing

        Ecodevelopment S.A

        University of Patras – Physics Department - Laboratory of Atmospheric Physics (LapUP)

        Dimitrios Vallianatos (IDCOM)

        Aristotle University of Thessaloniki

        University of Thessaly, Medical School. Laboratory of Hygiene and Epidemiology

      Italy

        Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale delle Venezie (IZSVe)

        Edmund Mach Foundation

        University of Trento

      Serbia

        University of "Novi Sad", Faculty of Agriculture, Laboratory for Medical and Veterinary Entomology

        Scientific Veterinary Institute "Novi Sad"

        University of Novi Sad, Faculty of Medicine

      Germany

        German Mosquito Control Association (KABS)

        Bernhard Nocht Institute for Tropical Medicine

      France

        EID Méditerranée

    West Nile Virus (WNV)

    Europe's eyes on Earth


    wnv
    European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC), 2013

    West Nile Virus (WNV)

    continental/regional scale


    EFSA and ECDC, 2021

    2018: All seasons were warmer than usual, with late spring, summer and autumn all seeing temperatures more than 1 above average

    West Nile Virus (WNV)

    prefecture/province/municipality scale

    2014-16: A minimum occurs after ~5y cycle.

    West Nile Virus (WNV) dynamics

    the EYWA approach

    Mesoscale monthly to seasonal

  • Causality Driven (forecasting)
    • Seek predictable signals in Input Data:
      • Environmental
      • Epidemiological
      • Entomological
      • Geographical
      • Demographical

      Key elements of the prediction process:
      • Meteorological Uncertainty
      • Epidemiological Uncertainty

    Microscale weekly to monthly

  • Data Driven (nowcasting)
  • Dynamical core of the EYWA system: the MIMESIS model

    MIMESIS: spatial dynaMIcal Model for wESt nIle viruS


    Kioutsioukis and Stylianakis, 2019
    Angelou, Kioutsioukis and Stilianakis, 2021 (under review)
    Kioutsioukis et al., 2021 (submitted)

    Conclusions

      Quantitative early warning assessments (t~months) of the spatial and temporal variability of WNV circulation in mosquitoes, birds and humans is a major challenge and requires a causative attribution.


      The MIMESIS model, developed at the LapUP, operates spatially at the mesoscale and temporally at the monthly to seasonal scale. It is a dynamic model nested in an ensemble framework to account for the meteorological and epidemiological uncertainty.

      • Meteorological uncertainty: ensemble seasonal forecasts.
      • Epidemiological uncertainty: relies in an ensemble model developed for this purpose.


      Average detection probability is 72% in GR and 94% in VE, in optimal sense. In forecast mode for 2020, it reached 66-83%.


      The May temperatures are found most critical in shaping the WNV dynamics.

    Thank you!

    More training material available at:

    http://www.eo4geo.eu/training-material-catalogue/


    More training actions available at:

    http://www.eo4geo.eu/training-actions/

    connection

    www.eo4geo.eu

    @EO4GEOtalks

    connection

    https://www.atmosphere-upatras.gr/en/